Round 1 Wrap-Up

It took over three months to get through the first round, when it should have taken me three months (or less) to get through the whole thing. Enough complaining.

So the first round is over with. What once was 32 games has been narrowed down to 16. Another step closer to determining what is my favorite videogame. Here is the list of all games, broken up by bracket, with the winners in bold. A summary appears after each listing.

-----

Bracket A
1. The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past
8. Pokemon Blue
4. Killer 7
5. Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars
3. James Bond 007: Nightfire
6. Metroid Prime
2. Tetris
7. Star Wars Knights of the Old Republic

The 1 seed was a clear victory in the opening match of the tournament, and higher seeds 2 and 3 also conquered their opponents. However, in the second match, the first underdog emerged. All respect goes to Pokemon, Killer 7, Metroid Prime, and Knights of the Old Republic, but the superior games were Link to the Past, Super Mario RPG, Nightfire, and Tetris. Things are already heating up.

-----

Bracket B
1. Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots
8. Chrono Trigger
4. Super Smash Bros. Brawl
5. Fire Emblem: Path of Radiance
3. The Legend of Zelda
6. Syphon Filter
2. NHL ‘94
7. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles 2: Arcade Game

The most recently released game on the list, MGS4, was an immediate 1 seed and (easier than it should have been) defeated Chrono Trigger. Higher seeds SSBB and NHL '94 removed Fire Emblem: PoR and TMNT 2, respectively. However, the biggest upset came in this bracket, when Syphon Filter overcame The Legend of Zelda. That was exciting. The first match for the next round will be a good one.

-----

Bracket C
1. Resident Evil 4
8. Mario Kart: Double Dash!!
4. Final Fantasy VII
5. Golden Sun
3. Super Mario Bros. 3
6. Castlevania: Aria of Sorrow
2. Guitar Hero III: Legends of Rock
7. Super Metroid

In one of the hardest matches for me, the 4 v 5, I went with a handheld RPG over one of the most well known and popular games ever made. Opinions differ my friends. All other top ranked seeds had it easy, but what would you expect from RE4 and GH3? SMB3 is one of those games nobody, especially myself, should look down on despite being a 3 seed.

-----

Bracket D
1. Tales of Symphonia
8. Halo 3
4. Contra
5. Metal Gear Solid
3. Metroid Prime 3: Corruption
6. Diablo II: Lord of Destruction
2. Fire Emblem
7. Kirby’s Adventure

Well, alas, the final bracket. This grouping was the only one that had all higher ranked seeds win their match ups. The closest match, as always, was the 4 v 5. One of the most interesting and most fun match up to write about was the 1 v 8; Tales vs. Halo 3. A lot of good memories came back to me, and that really helped in comparing the titles.

-----

The first round is officially done. Onto the second round! This will be referred to as both Round 2, and more interestingly, the Super 16. Super is an obvious reference to the SNES, and is more befitting that "sweet" in this instance. The competition will resume this week. The more organized brackets are as follows:

Bracket A
1. The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past
5. Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars
3. James Bond 007: Nightfire
2. Tetris


Bracket B
1. Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots
4. Super Smash Bros. Brawl
6. Syphon Filter
2. NHL ‘94

Bracket C
1. Resident Evil 4
5. Golden Sun
3. Super Mario Bros. 3
2. Guitar Hero III: Legends of Rock

Bracket D
1. Tales of Symphonia
4. Contra
3. Metroid Prime 3: Corruption
2. Fire Emblem

Also, a new design will be implemented for the Super 16. Yeah boy!

Flying is For Droids (Officially!)

Round 1 - Bracket D - Match 4

2. Fire Emblem

Vs.

7. Kirby's Adventure

This is it. We have finally made it to the end of round one. Fire Emblem blends amazing strategic gameplay with a very deep story in the first game of the series to see North America. Kirby's Adventure is a wonderfully imaginative game with the giant pink ball that can inhale virtually anything and absorb its power. Incredible.

-----

I loved playing Advance Wars on my GBA, so when I saw previews for Fire Emblem I got really excited. I was not let down. FE is hundreds of times better than AW. There was no need to capture cities and fund your army in FE, instead you had all of your characters ready to fight and move instantly. There were not different classes of units, instead every character was different. A Commanding Officer was not in charge off-site, but a lord commanded everybody and fought along side of them.

FE included three such lords: Lyn, Hector and Eliwood. If they die, then game over. If anyone dies, then they are gone for good. This added a whole lot of strategy to the game, since you did not just have to take out the enemies, but you had to keep your guys alive too. The fact that it was also an RPG made it better. Your characters earned experience from fights and leveled up. The stats we all randomly upgraded, and at a certain point you could upgrade a character's class to give them a boost in every category.

Along with the Golden Sun games, Fire Emblem is definitely a wonderful reason to own a GBA. It offered so much depth and strategic gameplay for a handheld game. This game should rank toward the top of my favorites because it gives me a majority of things I want in a videogame: character development, story, challenge, replayability, customization, etc. Why did it take so long for FE to reach America!?

-----

Kirby's Adventure was one of those games I could play as a youngling and adore. It was simple and friendly and (something I really love) colorful. Kirby must retrieve the Star Rod from King Dedede, and it takes him all over Dreamland. With the ability to inhale the enemies, Kirby could steal their powers and use them to advance. The coolest one was probably the cutter; it gave Kirby attitude.

Kirby's Adventure got easier as I got more experienced as a gamer. I can totally beat the game at 100% in about an hour. The bosses were pretty sweet (I do love boss fights) and the inclusion of having a Boss Rush mode was awesome. Of the sequels and remakes that this game has spawned, none are as good as the original. (Well, in the remake for the GBA youo could play the game as Meta-Knight, that was baller).

I consider this game a favorite because, as a gamer, I always have to return to my roots. Kirby's Adventure was one of the earliest games I was able to play, and play well. It is also so damn cute and adorable. Sometimes games do not need depth to be good, and Kirby is a great example.

-----

So, if our main characters from these games decided to fight, who would win? That could sort of be seen in Super Smash Bros., but unfortunately, Hector was not a playable character. Lyn is an assist trophey though, and Eliwood is kind of bland when compared to Marth or Ike. This is not even close to the topic at hand, so I will just end this abruptly and leave the conclusion for the Round 1 wrap-up.

Winner: Fire Emblem

Mega Man 9

One of the truest tests of a gamer is his ability to beat a Mega Man game.

My test is being administered this week, seeing as how I purchased Mega Man 9 on my Nintendo Wii this afternoon. Immediately I felt overjoyed for finally putting some of my Wii points to good use (weeks after Super Mario RPG, mind you) and I was feeling that nostalgia which comes with a game that looks as if it had been designed 15 years ago.

I love the direction the producers took with this game. Going with the retro look and feel is cool, and it leaves very little room for disappointment. Right away, fans know what they are getting into; Mega Man 9 looks, feels and plays like Mega Man 2. Simple controls literally take you back to the days of only two buttons: jump and shoot. What more do you really need?


My favorite part about the game is the soundtrack. 8-bit music never sounded so good. The tunes are catchy as hell, and throughout the deaths and pitfalls, I cannot ever get really upset because the music just raises my spirits back up.

But the one point I need to address the heaviest is the difficulty. Mega Man games have unforgiving enemies that will relentlessly repeat the same attack pattern. The ones on edges will hit you and send you backwards, resulting in a freefall to your death, whether it be onto spikes, into liquid hot magma, or to oblivion.


Playing for an hour and a half this afternoon, I only reached a boss fight twice. Twice. There are eight levels to start with, and I could only reach the end of said levels on two separate occasions. Of the two, I was only within my power to defeat one, Galaxy Man. His level was very innovatively designed and fresh, and his battle was maybe the easiest of the bosses I have faced thus far. However, it takes a lot of me to say that a Mega Man boss was easy.

What have I gotten myself into? Downloading a game the day it comes out? Spending 1000 Wii points for a game that was not made for the N64? Well, I must say I do not regret it. Mega Man 9 is truly a challenge, and not many games today are this challenging. In gaming, in order to find out where we are going, we must first look at where we have been. Mega Man 9 is a great throwback to the NES days, and I strongly recommend gamers who want to challenge themselves to download this. (It is available on Wii, PS3 and Xbox).

Round 1 - Bracket D - Match 3

3. Metroid Prime 3: Corruption

Vs.

6. Diablo II: Lord of Destruction

Let us look at two games that took big steps up from their predecessors. What Metroid Prime 3: Corruption did was keep the stunning visuals and awesome gameplay from the first two MP games and included larger worlds and the best Wii controls (and best FPS controls) for any game. Diablo II gave players a much more expansive world as players couold choose from more character options and fight more demons. More on this later.

-----

I waited months after getting my Wii for Metroid Prime 3: Corruption. I wished that it had been a launch game, and I think it was supposed to be at first, but it was pushed back about a year. Thus, the first week of my sophomore year I bought it and played it and loved it. Right away I knew it was wait, for it was far better than MP 1 and 2.

What improved? Well, movement was not all that great in the first two, because in typical FPS control schemes, both analog sticks are utilized for movement and aim. MP had more of a Goldeneye control, since Samus needs to jump and shoot contsantly. MP3 made that much better by allowing movement to the joystick and aiming with the Wiimote. Shooting was mapped to A and jumping with B, which I think worked, and the weapons were layered, so there was no need to switch back and forth (and none of that pesky ammo to worry about).

This game is worth getting a Wii for. It truly is one of the best adventure games on the market. MP redefined what a FPS could be, and Corruption just improved on the same formula. The story was deeper than the first two, which was great with the voice acting and videos; there was not a heavy reliance on the lore as the first two had. My biggest gripe was searching for the power cells or whatever they were. Slowed the pace down, and we all know MP games are paced wonderfully.

-----

The first Diablo was pretty interesting. A very different game than what I was used to. Although I am not a heavy PC gamer, because I never had a gaming quality PC and probably never will (I play games Half-Life 1 and Diablo II for crying out loud). But Diablo was a very intense game based mostly on the scenery. A very dark and cramped area with demons and beasts around every corner, who never show remorse and do not think twice about wanting to take your head off.

Diablo II: Lord of Destruction improved on one thing that I wanted most: the ability to run. Gameplay moved quicker by running, and having to backtrack did not seem so tedious. The environment was opened up, no longer confining the player to the depths of a church which led directly to hell. Locations opened up to plains and deserts and forests. Dungeon crawling was still an essential element to the game, but it was not the only element.

Diablo II might as well be my favorite Blizzard game, probably because I never played any Warcraft games and I am awful at Starcraft. More than three character classes allows even more replayability within the game; there are seven to choose from with the expansion. Going online and playing with other demon slayers is pretty cool too; the worlds always change and there is never the same map twice. Plus, something that all RPGs should let you do: level up. Diablo II is one of those games where you can do nothing but still make a lot of progress with your character.

-----

Both of these games make great examples of how to improve what is already great for the sequel. Sometimes gamers are disappointed with a subpar sequel, but both of these games are the best of their respective series. Although Diablo II could be my favorite PC game (strictly PC, not ported or remade, etc.) Metroid Prime 3 is higher up there for me. A little less aggrivating to paly, maybe not as rewarding, but a whole lot of fun to explore and play around it.

Winner: Metroid Prime 3: Corruption

Round 1 - Bracket D - Match 2

4. Contra

Vs.

5. Metal Gear Solid

Games of epic proportions face off against one another. Contra is the best run and gun game I can think of. The entire game is run and gun. And jump. Metal Gear Solid is an astounding story presented in the shape of a game, with one of the greatest stories ever told in a game.

-----

Up Up Down Down Left Right Left Right B A Select Start. I dare anybody to beat this game without inputting the Konami Code at the beginning of the game. I doubt that I could beat the first level without it. Contra is notorious for being a ridiculously difficult game. One of the hardest without the Konami Code. The enemies punish you by firing ceaseless amounts of bullets or lasers at you.

The premise of the game is simple: run from left to right, jump around, shoot anything that moves, and just try to avoid being hit. The execution, on the other hand, is far less forgiving. One hit and you are dead. That Spreader that you had is gone forever now. The Automatic Rifle is no more; back to having to press the button to fire instead of holding it down. Yeah, the weapons were pretty sick. The laser was awful, though. And that fire gun. I am all about the spreader.

Contra is one of my favorite 8-bit games (duh, it made the list) and I would not be a gamer if I had never played it. Hell, I would not be a gamer if I did not know what the Konami Code was. There should be a test administered to gamers and the first question is "What is the Konami Code?" If that is answered incorrectly, then an automatic fail. Contra's simple premise and hardcore difficult makes this game a classic.

-----

I must admit to have played Twin Snakes, the remake, before I ever played the original Metal Gear Solid. I must also admit to playing MGS 1, 2 and 3 for the first time this summer. I just knew that after Twin Snakes and knowing that MGS4 was coming out (best reason for buying a PS3) I needed to go to the original. Was it better? Well, look what copy made it to the list. Controls were a step down, as well as graphics. But the original had way better sound and feel to it overall. The voice actors were the same, but I never knew that Naomi and Mei Ling had accents to begin with. They should have kept them.

The story is what is mind blowing about this game. It is so intense that on subsequent playthoughs (not speedruns) I end up watching them all over again and gain a little bit more out of the plot each time. There are so many cheeky elements involved too, those just make me giggle everytime. For instance, Ocelot stares you (the player) in the eyes and tells you not to cheat with a turbo controller; and Mantis reads your memory card to see how often you have been saving and what other games you like to play.

I keep coming back to this game every once in a while for maybe a weekend of gaming because of how epic the story is. It is not as ambitious as the sequels (I still cannot wrap my head completely around 2 or 4; 3 is a bit easier to comprehend, it is the characters in 3 that are the most confusing, not the story) but the story in MGS is simple (eek) in the fact that the bad guys stole REX and you need to stop them. Tons of character development takes place as awesome filler.

-----

Konami is well represented in this match up. Both games offer something different. Contra delivers quick action-packed playing without having to understand what in the world is going on with the final boss. Metal Gear Solid can be played quickly (I have done it in under four hours) but it should not be; the story is not one to miss. This is one of the hardest match ups to come up with a clear winner on. My head says one, my heart says the other. I'll go with my head on this one.

Winner: Contra

Round 1 - Bracket D - Match 1

1. Tales of Symphonia

Vs.

8. Halo 3

This list was thrown together over the summer, almost three months ago. Tales of Symphonia is exactly where it belongs, without question. Halo 3? Well, I put it there because that is how I felt then. Also because I had not played Call of Duty 4. However, I will stick with what it is (as if it would change the outcome, just saying).

-----

I could name a handful of games that I would consider my favorites right away, and Tales of Symphonia was one of them. Since I have not said it enough: Tales of Symphonia is the game that inspired my choice of career. It is a legendary story of how I wrote the review online for GamePro and saw it published in the December 2004 issue under the name TinyTim531. Seeing my work in a wide read magazine was astonishing, I horripilate every time I think about it. I decided I wanted to do that for a living.

I cannot say enough words to do ToS the justice it deserves. You need to either experience it yourself or just see me while I play it. I stumble and just freeze at this keyboard when I think of something next to say. Story is there. Depth is there. Quality is for sure there. Gameplay is there like woah. Like. Woah. Replayability is there (but it should not be overdone). This game is paced amazingly. The battle system is the greatest I have ever experienced. It is exciting everytime, even when fighting three wimple little bunny rabbits. Boss battles. BOSS BATTLES!!!

One paragraph is not enough to explain why this game should be considered a favorite. I should just write an essay about why ToS is the best RPG ever (saying best RPG for GCN would be easy, it has like three games to compete with). When building an RPG, do not consider games like FFVII or Chrono Trigger or Dragon Warrior. Think Tales of Symphonia. Turn-based games are still okay, but lets keep things fresh, eeh?

-----

When I talk Halo 3, I mean very few things about the game. I could care less about the story. I could care less about the graphics. I could care less about the gameplay (it is FPS, that is all I can say). What matters to me about playing Halo 3, especially my spring semester sophomore year, is its multiplayer. Not online multiplayer by itself, I mean multiplayer where I get to play with the people that are close to me and have a good time pwning noobs.

I do not see how this game can be played alone. That would be sad. The campaign mode is insanely cool with four people all at once. It creates for some serious Covenant ass-kicking and more importantly, comradery. You want more fun than throwing a sticky grenade at a Brute? Throw one at the back of your buddy's head. Online with a full team of your pals can mean intense, well-thought out tactics and shooting. Or it can mean just running around, joking, trying to splatter as many people as you can with the Ghost on Snowbound.

What I do not get with Call of Duty 4 is playing online with my friends. Halo 3 let me do that on a nightly basis. I threw this game in last on my list for favorite contention, but it still should get some recognition. I spent three months with an XBox Live account to reach level 30 on Team Slayer. I also spent those three months having a grand time with my boys on second floor Saxe. Jeez, I am getting all teary-eyed.

-----

Halo 3 put up a good fight against a heavy favorite. It is obvious when reading this when the top seeded team will just win because of the lack of love the other game gets. Halo 3 gets a lot of love. Valiant effort. It is one of those things I will miss. Tales of Symphonia though is Tales of Symphonia. There is no way to get around that. Dwarven Vow #7: Goodness and love will always win.

Winner: Tales of Symphonia

Round 1 - Bracket C - Match 4

2. Guitar Hero III: Legends of Rock

Vs.

7. Super Metroid

We are almost there; three quarters of the way through the first round. To finish off Bracket C, Guitar Hero III: Legends of Rock with go into a pro face off against Super Metroid. Probably playing Dragonforce. No, not really. Writing these intros has become stale and banal. The second round's will be more exciting. So much closer. I cannot wait for it.

-----

Are you ready to rock!?!?!?!?!? Guitar Hero III: Legends of Rock is my favorite of the rock simulation games because of its playability. Notes are easier to hit and therefore the gameplay is more rewarding. Online mode is excellent; it definitely beats playing a song by myself when I can own a random stranger online. Best part about Wii's online mode: more people are playing online with the Wii than there are people playing on XBox Live.

My Wii version does not have downloadable content, but I am over it. I do not really need most of those songs anyway. Something to look forward to is that World Tour will have the very first downloadable content for any Wii game. The peripherals look much better than any previous installment's, and the drums look better than Rock Band's.

I love playing Guitar Hero. There have been times when I get so carried away that it is so hard for me to stop playing. Best songs? Reptilia, Helicopter, My Name is Jonas, One, 3's and 7's, Knights of Cydonia, Cliffs of Dover, Cities on Flame With Rock and Roll. Love these songs. If I could just throw together all the best songs from all GH games, I would be so happy. Mr. Fix It.

-----

Super Metroid is without a doubt the best 2D Metroid game around. It really is the third game of the series, but plotwise it takes place before Metroid Fusion, and Samus and the Galactic Federation are trying to take back the last surviving Metroid. It is not a bad Metroid, it thinks Samus is its mother. And thankfully too, because it **SPOILER** sacrifices itself in the end during the battle with Mother Brain.

Super Metroid has a gigantic world to explore and re-explore times over. It has some epic boss battles (most specifically Kraid and Ridley). Classic elements are at play, and the introduction of the grapple beam, among other items, create a brilliant gameplay that is always progressive and sometimes frustrating.

Metroid games are amazing, and Super Metroid is one of my favorite SNES games because of how different it is from a lot of other games that are in my SNES collection. Maybe not my favorite Metroid game (that might have already been discussed), despite having the cartridge I really wanted to download it to my Wii (nope, saved the 800 points for Super Mario RPG, as you might have heard).

-----

These sometimes seem like lopsided battles. I know who will come out the victor beforehand, and when I get halfway through the post, it becomes a little harder to carry on. But it s the first round; the time to separate the men from the boys, so to speak. While Samus is neither a man nor boy (but a hot chick), she falls to Guitar Hero's rocking awesomeness.

Winner: Guitar Hero III: Legends of Rock

Round 1 - Bracket C - Match 3

3. Super Mario Bros. 3

Vs.

6. Castlevania: Aria of Sorrow

I find it odd to introduce matchups like this when the games are so different. Well, both Super Mario Bros. 3 and Castelvania: Aria of Sorrow are 2D side-scrolling games, so that is a start. One comes from a very classic franchise, and the other comes from a slightly lesser but still classic nonetheless franchise.

-----

Mario has spanned decades of gaming on every Nintendo system possible. His greatest game may be argued as the first Super Mario Bros., but the third installment really works much better. The world map is an incredible way of breaking between levels, allowing you to pick up a lucky item or earn some extra lives while scoping out the territories ahead. It also gave a better look at the Mushroom Kingdom (a complete look that is missed by those bastards who use the warp whistles to go quickly to the later stages). It is much more fun do play every single level in the game, especially with a pal controlling Luigi.

He can run, he can jump, he can fly, swim, turn to stone, toss hammers, throw fireballs, hop around in a frog suit... basically Mario is the perfect choice to save the kidnapped princess, again. I should not really have to say anything about this game because virtually everyone has played this game in their lifetime. It may be the most recognizable game in this challenge, and looking at the full list, it might as well be. Another timeless gem.

This game made the favorite list because I have these memories as a child playing through the first level, grabbing the leaf and flying up into the clouds, gathering an unnecessary amount of coins, dropping behind the white rectangles, and grabbing the star at the end of the level. I do not have to be in any kind of a mood to play this game, it can just be done by picking up the controller and getting down to business.

-----

Of all the Castlevania games, I choose one that does not even star a Belmont as the main character (granted Julius makes an appearance and becomes playable after complettion). Another thing, Aria of Sorrow does not even give the main character the classic vampire killing whip. Instead, Soma Cruz wields a variety of weapons (the best being the Claimh Solais) like swords, knives, spears, and a handgun (which is garbage and a cheap way to defeat the antagonist at the end).

Another crazy thing about this very anti-Castlevania Castlevania game is that Soma can steal the souls of defeated enemies and use their powers as his own (like shooting fireballs, stealing health with each hit, and turning into a bat). You can gain experience points with defeated enemies, adding a nice RPG element to the action game. These souls also help in solving the few puzzles presented and advancing through the castle.

Although I have never played this actual game on the GBA, and I have the ROM on my computer (I am not advocating downloading ROMs, however convenient they may be) and it might as well be the most played game on my computer. I have played it at least once a year and find it all exciting everytime, there are really no dull moments since progressing through the game always gives you something new. Replay is also great as Julius, because you get to start off all pimped out.

-----

I find it unlucky for C:AoS (I just got that pun; "Chaos" is the final-final boss) being paired against SMB3 in the first round because of how great of a game I find it to be. It is a fresh and different Castlevania that helped repopularize the genre. However, Mario is Mario, and SMB3 is like the Holy Grail of NES games. I wish I had my NES up at school right now.

Winner: Super Mario Bros. 3

Bonus Post

Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars has been made available on Virtual Console today. I now have a perfectly reasonable excuse for not updating regularly this week. Sorry homework.

Round 1 - Bracket C - Match 2

4. Final Fantasy VII

Vs.

5. Golden Sun

RPG madness! Of the six or so true RPGs that made the tournament, this is the first head-to-head match up. Final Fantasy VII has you and your team fighting to save the world, while Golden Sun has you and your team... well, also trying to save the world. Pretty standard plot when it comes to RPGs.

-----

Okay, I am going to start off by saying I have only played through FFVII completely once. Only once. That means from start to finish. However, even one playthrough requires a lot of hours, and then some more when hitting sidequests and leveling and raising chocobos and leveling and gaining AP and leveling... and leveling.

All the RPG elements are here in FFVII, but they are presented differently from other games. This FF story does not take place somewhere in the past, instead it takes place in a futuristic world that is falling apart. Nothing is perfect. Not even the main character. Cloud may be the biggest anti-hero to be the hero ever. His life practically falls apart all around him. He discovers that he has been living a lie for years, and you can see that he isn't perfect all the way till the very end when he defeats Sephiroth. It still does not make things right for him. Very unique story telling.

I do not know what I love more about FFVII, the game itself or all of the lore that encompasses it. Advent Children is one of my top ten favorite movies. The game is an awesome RPG, and millions of people will agree with me on that. It is an incredibly deep game that deserves multiple playthroughs, if not begs for them.

-----

Golden Sun is the very first game I bought with my Gameboy Advance. And it was awesome. For a handheld game, it was visually stunning and captivating with many good moments that beg you to keep playing and go deeper into the story. Isaac, a classic silent protagonist, is thrown into being the hero like so many other RPG leads; and although this whole game is very archetypal, it works and still feels fresh everytime I play it.

The sequel was in immediate purchase because the game left such a huge cliffhanger at the end. Only two of the lighthouses were lit; Felix and Jenna were lost at sea; and the world was still falling apart. But I am getting way ahead of myself. The first game only showed you half of the problem, and you were fighting against it for the wrong reasons. The second game corrected that and showed you the truth (and the whole rest of the world via magically flying boat).

Golden Sun begs to be my favorite handheld game. It begs that all other RPGs should be played like this. IT BEGS FOR A THIRD TITLE TO REALLY REVEAL WHAT HAPPENED TO ALEX AT THE END OF GS2!!! He could not have died. He was too powerful and too big of a badass. I could get rid of my GBA after six years of good use, but then I would miss out on two (this and the sequel) of the greatest RPGs (and games in general) that I have ever played.

-----

So, do you think you know who emerged victorious after this turn-based battle? I know you (the millions of other readers I get) are convinced that FFVII should win this tournament all together. I mean, so many others have ranked this at the top of their list. But do not overlook that I am deciding which of these games are MY FAVORITE, not necessarily the best of all time or anything like that. Which is why I favor Golden Sun as a game over Final Fantasy VII. I have said this before and I will say it again: a decade from now if I do this whole bracket challenge again, things may change.

Winner: Golden Sun